Shopify: Template Design Quality

Arbitration Result

Status
completed
Resolved Value
premium
Positive Spin
Premium, professionally designed templates.
Reasoning
Cross-source normalization shows strongest consensus around high-quality template design. CNET repeatedly uses 'premium' to describe Shopify templates, and WebsiteBuilderExpert’s 'expertly designed' / 'excellent' terms align with a premium positioning. Normalize to the common high-quality descriptor: premium.
Completed At
12/15/2025, 2:39:29 PM
ClaimSuggested ValueConfidence
Shopify templates: are optimized for sellingconversion-optimized90.0%
Shopify: premade section designs are underwhelminglow90.0%
Shopify premium templates: typically cost between $200 and $500premium80.0%
Shopify premium templates: are priced between $200 and $500premium80.0%
Shopify: offers excellent qualityexcellent70.0%
Shopify: offers 220 premium templatespremium90.0%
Shopify Magic: increased detail in its theme generation reduced the relevance of its themeshigh60.0%
Shopify premium templates: are considered a relatively low cost by many e-commerce storesPremium60.0%
Shopify templates: are attractiveattractive85.0%
Shopify templates: are mobile-friendlymobile-friendly90.0%
Shopify Magic: offers attractive themes created by its first toolattractive90.0%
Shopify Dawn theme: is very basicbasic60.0%
Shopify templates: are expertly designed with online stores in mindexpertly designed80.0%
Shopify store builder: is elegantelegant80.0%
Shopify templates: use responsive designresponsive design80.0%
Shopify Magic: the first tool required a few attempts to generate a theme relevant to the selected industryindustry_relevant60.0%
Shopify premium templates: are specialized for high fashionpremium80.0%
Shopify premium templates: are specialized for techpremium80.0%
Shopify premium templates: are prohibitively expensive for small startup budgetspremium80.0%